曝光臺 注意防騙 網曝天貓店富美金盛家居專營店坑蒙拐騙欺詐消費者

3.68 Dr Donohoe told the inquiry:
I am saying that in this case we have doctors and toxicologists saying that there are long-term health problems. In other words, people who have been exposed to these fumes and developed short-term symptoms at the time have had long-term consequences.71
3.69 Dr Teo in his evidence to the inquiry stated:
… the people I have tested have been affected about two years, and they are still not good. So for two years I can say they are not good. 72
3.70 Dr Robert Loblay put a contrary view at the hearing in Sydney on 1 February 2000:
Almost anything can be toxic if given in sufficiently large dose or if a person is exposed to a sufficient quantity. The real question is: are the people in the cabin – under normal cabin conditions, not when there is a leak – exposed to levels of any of these compounds which could conceivably cause toxic effects? The evidence the expert panel was presented with seemed pretty clear, that that was not at all likely.73
70  Submission 22, Ansett Australia, p 5 
71  Dr Mark Donohoe, Evidence, 1 February 2000, p. 95 
72  Dr Richard Teo, Evidence, 1 February 2000, p. 95 
73  Dr Robert Loblay , Evidence, 1 February 2000, p 105 

Other clinical symptoms
3.71 It is apparent that although some crew members have reacted to the fumes on the BAe 146, other crew members have had limited, or no reaction to the same exposure. One confidential submission to the inquiry advised that it appeared women were more susceptible than men to the fumes.74 Dr Winder stated:
There are a whole range of individual reasons why exposure may be increased and also a whole range of issues related to susceptibility. … There are a range of different factors which may underlie why some people are more affected than others.75
3.72 Dr Balouet told the inquiry in evidence:
… individual susceptibility is not the same with all people around the world and even within a small population. Some people would be really allergic, for example, to a compound and others would not. …
There might be genetic factors interfering with these problems. In fact, there are a number of enzymes, one of which especially play a major role in eliminating and controlling the effects of organophosphates. Particularly what we have seen from the preliminary studies is that the people sharing the two same enzymes will show very high effects, while those people who have either the R type or the 2 plus R type will not have such severe symptoms.76
3.73 In his evidence to the inquiry Dr Chris van Netten noted that:
The most sensitive people get sick first and they are your early warning signs of a potential problem. Often these people are looked upon as hypochondriacs or complainers or whatever else, and this is doing the system an injustice because it is actually quite dangerous to not pay attention to these people. They are really your early warning signs that something is wrong. The person next to you might get sick now because of a certain different physiology or background whereas you might get sick next, and this is the important component we have to worry about.77
　
中國航空網 www.k6050.com
航空翻譯 www.aviation.cn
本文鏈接地址：Air Safety and Cabin Air Quality in the BAe 146 Aircraft(49)